Render: D- ...its like stretched and very blurry
Creativity: C ...u got the general idea of wut a sig should be
Color/Background: D ...looks like shit but colors are good
Text: F- ..keep all the text together
Overall:D
p.s. make border smaller, dont put effects over top the whole render, add some flow. I definetely have seen alot worse for 1st/2nd sigs so keep your head up champ